ST ANDREW. Low down, close to the estuary of the river Tavy. A church of considerable interest in that it belongs essentially to a period earlier than nearly all South Devon village churches. It consists of nave, long transepts, and chancel, plus S aisle, S porch, and S chancel-aisle. Its building history has not yet been sufficiently elucidated. The style of all but the aisle and porch points to two dates, c. 1300 and c. 1330, and the principal recorded date is the foundation of an Archpresbytery with an archpriest and four priests in 1333. The N transept arch and the recess in the N transept (both of blue stone) appear earliest. Of the windows some are cusped lancets or two-light cusped lancets with a pointed quatrefoil above, others are clearly Dec. Cf. also the three Piscinas and the Sedilia, and the W tower, thin and unbuttressed. Only the S aisle and chancel aisle (see the A-type piers and the depressed moulded arches) and the two-storeyed S porch with a handsome ribbed ceiling are later. - FONT. Circular, Norman, perhaps made up of two capitals. If so, they would be evidence of a previous Norman church. - ALTAR-STONE. A curious blue stone plate behind the present altar, decorated with rose tracery on a honeycomb ground. Can it be part of the original decoration of the chancel? - SCREEN. Only the Wainscoting remains. - BENCHES. Many, and not only bench ends as usual. Decorated with large, i.e. one-tier, blank traceried arches. - STAINED GLASS. A specially precious possession of the church. In the E window part of the early C14 glass. Christ seated in the centre Light, the Ferrers donor and his wife kneeling in the outer lights. Also figures of saints, less complete, and smaller fragments in the tracery. The colouring still with the glow which later medieval English glass so often lacks. - MONUMENTS. Excellent original white limestone recess in the N chancel wall, with big cusped arch under crocketed gable - no ogee details. Under the arch in the recess the slender (alas, poorly preserved) figures of a cross-legged knight and a lady wearing a wimple. The cusps end in fine heads; in the gable two censing angels. Such angels appear in St James’ Chapel, Exeter Cathedral, about 1290, the head cusps in the Richard de Stapleton monument at Exeter Cathedral of c. 1320. The effigies at Bere Ferrers may represent Sir William de Ferraris and his wife Matilda. - In the N transept another original recess, the arch of blue stone with the effigy of a cross-legged knight. - Also a dark grey free-standing tomb-chest with shields in Early Renaissance wreaths, said to be for Lord Willoughby de Broke, d. 1522. In the churchyard the tombstone of the elder Stothard, the artist-antiquarian.
Index
Thursday, 24 October 2019
Bere Ferrers, Devon
Wednesday, 23 October 2019
St Germans, Cornwall
Processing my photographs showed what a complex building this is - more of a priory church than your run of the mill parish church. The highlights are the aforesaid chancel window, an early Rysbrack monument, an interesting font, the atmospheric interior and the west doorway and its fish handle.
ST GERMANUS. The church was the cathedral of Cornwall in Anglo-Saxon times. Bishops are known between 931 and c.1040, but no architectural fragments remain. In 1050 the bishopric, with that of Crediton, was merged in a new diocese, with its see at Exeter. Between 1161 and 1184 Bishop Bartholomew reorganized St Germans as a priory of Augustinian canons. Of this building, finally consecrated only in 1261, so much is still in existence that no other church in Cornwall can vie with it as an example of Norman planning. The Norman building had two W towers, a nave of 102 ft, two narrow aisles with lean-to roofs, and probably a chancel, but no transept and no crossing tower. Of the E part nothing is left. The W front, however, stands complete up to roof height. The aisle width and height can be read from traces against the E walls of the S tower inside and the N tower outside. Of the nave the first two s bays survive. It had a clerestory with windows in line with the spandrels, not, as usual, with the apexes of the arches (cf. the upper N wall of the S aisle), a motif which such Gothic churches as Fowey, Lostwithiel, and Callington in Cornwall, and North Petherwin in Devon took up.
The W front is uncommonly plain and powerful for its date. With the wide flat buttresses of the two towers it is more reminiscent of Franco-Norman work of a hundred years earlier (say St Etienne at Caen) than of the livelier Transitional which more central parts of England practised towards the end of the C12. Between the towers is on the ground floor a porch under a gable (with the rare feature of a cross), and on the upper floor three round-headed windows with the centre one higher than the others. These windows are provided with nook-shafts. Higher up the S tower has four small Norman windows towards W and E and otherwise Perp work. The N tower turns into octagonal shape on the second storey (cf. Jumiéges) and ends in a C13 octagon. The W portal under the gable is unrivalled in Cornwall. It is of seven orders, built of elvan from Tartan Down near Landrake. Three of the orders and voussoirs have uncommonly vivid zigzag; whether the innermost order possessed different ornaments cannot now be said, as the material has weathered very badly. The hood mould of the outer arch exhibits foliage decoration.
Inside, the ground floors of the towers were open to nave and aisles by transitional pointed arches of simplest design: two steps with an inserted roll moulding (cf. Morwenstow). The capitals of the clustered wall-shafts are mostly scalloped, but some also of a very primitive ‘Ionic’ kind. On the first floor the towers were connected by a gallery, as indicated by the two remaining doors. The staircase of the S tower is the only Cornish staircase of Norman date. In the nave, the two bays which are preserved have thick, short, circular piers, with square scalloped capitals and pointed arches of plain two-step moulding. The clerestory windows, which were discovered in 1904, have rich zigzag ornament.
With no more than these bays (and what has been re-used of Norman fragments in the other S bays after the collapse of the chancel in 1592) belonging to the original building of the C12 and C13, the interior of St Germans is now more interesting than inspiring. It is dominated by the late Middle Ages and the C19. The proportions, with the aisle 6 ft wider than the nave, are unhappy, the C13 chancel (consecrated 1261) went 55 ft beyond the present E wall, and the C19 roofs are disappointing. The N transept was built in 1803 for the Port Eliot pew. (But the transept arch has re-used Norman fragments.) The S aisle is a mixture of four styles: the Norman of the first bays, the interesting imitation-Norman of probably after 1592, the Dec of the E end, and the early C15 Perp of the rest. The E end must originally have been an E chapel attached to the narrow Norman aisle. It is of high aesthetic quality, derived in style from Exeter Cathedral. To get an impression of its pristine finesse of detail St Ive near Liskeard, consecrated in 1338, may be compared. It seems difficult therefore to connect the chapel with the transfer of relics of St German in 1358. The E wall of the chapel has two three-light windows with a niche for an image between (cf. the niches of St Ive). In the S wall are one original window and a recess with an ogee canopy. The S aisle itself can be dated by the arms of Bishop Lacy (1420-50) amongst the shields on the hood moulds of one of the windows. There are four such windows, all of four lights, three clearly Perp, the fourth (on the W) still reticulated, that is Dec. The aisle is battlemented outside (like the S tower) and has a handsome and original S porch with two entrance arches close to each other to W and S and a depressed tunnel-vault with a grid of thick granite ribs. Perp also the five-light chancel E window, which must have been put into the present E wall when the chancel was taken down. - FONT. Of Purbeck marble, c.1200; badly preserved. - WOODWORK. Only minor remains: one choir stall (misericord with a man called Dando, punished for hunting on Sunday), c.1375-1400; fragment of the rood screen; figure of St Anthony, indifferent, c.1500, brought over from Port Eliot. - STAINED GLASS. E window by Burne Jones, 1896. To see such work executed by Morris and Co. after the many other Victorian windows in Cornish churches brings home most forcibly the value of William Morris’s reform. Here are clear outlines, pleasing patterns, and simple colours in sufficiently large expanses to be taken in individually. No overcrowding, no competing with the art of painting, and yet a sentiment that is wholly of the C19. - Coloured wooden STATUE of St Nicholas. - MONUMENTS. John Moyle d. 1661. Large tomb-chest (in the vestry) with a heraldic device in bas-relief on a black marble slab (G. W. Copeland). – Edward Eliot, 1722 by Rysbrack, reclining on a sarcophagus, in Roman costume, with an allegorical figure on his l., mourning. Short pyramid in relief and putti in the background: a first-rate example of Rysbrack’s art and the most ambitious C18 monument in Cornwall. - First Earl of St Germans d. 1823, by R. Westmacott, a sad maiden seated by a tall pillar with an urn.
St Austell, Cornwall
The chief attractions here are the tower statuary and carving, a fantastic font with cover and what appear to be redundant bench ends in the tower. Also what I mistook for a benefactions board turned out to be "a letter to the inhabitants of the county of Cornwall" from Charles I dated 1643.
HOLY TRINITY. The most noteworthy feature of the tower is its enrichment on all four faces by figure sculpture in niches. On N, E, and S are four apostles each, on the W is a pyramidal group of the Trinity at the top, Annunciation below, with the lily as an isolated motif between the two kneeling figures, and the risen Christ between two saints at the foot. The style is that familiar from C15 alabaster work, rather hard and stocky. The top of the tower, with the usual pinnacles, has four strips of ornament of the type as found at Launceston or St Mary Truro, or Fowey.* The tower can be dated by the coat of arms of Bishop Courtenay (1478-87). It is faced with Pentewan stone. Interior of nave with five bays, chancel with two bays, N and S aisles, two-storeyed S porch. Mainly C15. Of earlier buildings the following fragments or parts can still be seen: the circular pier of the S chancel arcade, the two responds of the arches, and the double-chamfered arches themselves are early C13 ; the N chancel arcade is also E.E., but later, with a handsome octagonal pier with four slim attached shafts in the diagonals, a motif which comes from Dartmouth and its neighbourhood; the chancel E window and N aisle E window with intersecting tracery and pointed quatrefoils look c.1300, and it is quite probable that they and the N chancel aisle can be connected with the date c.1290, recorded for the endowment of a chantry chapel of St Michael. The nave is disappointing inside, much restored in 1872 (by G. E. Street. The alabaster reredos and pulpit are his). The piers are slender, of standard Cornish section, with moulded capitals and on the s side some decoration of the abaci. The aisles have wide Perp windows giving an even light. The old wagon roofs are original; they rest almost immediately on the arcades. Outside, the church is much more attractive, with battlemented aisles and a battlemented, buttressed, two-storeyed S porch with a curious doorway with openwork tracery: an ogee arch inscribed into a round one (cf. Mylor, St Just-in-Roseland; the motif really originated at Gloucester and is to be found, for example, in tomb canopies at Tewkesbury). There are also carved shield-holding angels, and shields with carved Instruments of the Passion, Resurrection, Ascension, and Christ in Glory. - FONT. Norman, of Bodmin type, with faces at the corners, ‘trees of life’, and dragons. - PILLAR PISCINA. Norman, and of interesting design. - BENCH ENDS. Only a few are preserved; and only a small part (on the S) of the ROOD SCREEN. - CLOCK FACE outside the W tower, with twenty-four bosses for the hours; probably C16. - OAK CHEST. 1669. - PLATE. Two similar gilt Cups, with strapwork decoration, London, 1573-4; also pieces of 1707, 1708, 1751, 1753. - MONUMENT to Joeseph Sawle d. 1769, by Isbell. Free standing, about 6 ft high; black urn on a square base.
* Mr A. L. Rowse calls this a Somerset type of tower - a class which extends in a band all the way across the West Country from Cornwall to Oxford. The elaborately carved stonework of the topmost stage is typical. (St Austell, H. E. Warne, 1960.)
ST AUSTELL. We may wonder at the sight of something like a range of snowcapped peaks as we come to it on a summer's day, but here they are, apparently eternally, the work of a Quaker who turned St Austell upside down, changing its green valleys to white hills.
For centuries the neighbourhood has been famous for its tin, now it is famous for white clay. It was here that William Cookworthy found his first examples of the clay which was to give Cornwall a new industry. He found it here before he discovered the huge deposits at Carclaze mine, one of the sights of Cornwall two miles away. Open to the day, the great Carclaze mine has been quarried for tin from time immemorial. It must have been yielding tin when the Phoenicians came this way. It astonishes us by its immensity, a mile round and 150 feet deep, a match for the great slate quarry at Delabole. From it go pipes to Charlestown, .the liquid clay running along them to be dried and shipped for the Potteries.
The moors are honeycombed with mines and quarries. There is a wishing well on the Bodrnin Road, an old stone by the church where tradition says a witch was burned alive, and a stream hereabouts that yielded a rare treasure for the British Museum behind which is a queer story. A thousand years ago, when the Vikings were harrying Cornwall, a Saxon priest hid his treasure in a heap of loose stones under a slate. His chief treasure was a silver chalice of King Alfred’s day and small ornaments and a silver wire with a glass bead at the end. Slowly the earth covered the hoard till it was 17 feet deep, and at last the tin miners of St Austell brought it to light. The silver wire with the bead at the end is known as a scourge, and is said to be the only complete one of its kind.
The fine church in the heart of this busy town stands among palm trees, rising from a lovely lawn. We see its tower from far away standing on a hillside among the trees. Five centuries old and 90 feet high to its battlements, it is one of the finest towers in Cornwall, with rich pinnacles, and grotesques on the walls looking as though they would leap down. On three sides of the tower are the Twelve Apostles and on the west wall are sculptured groups showing souls in Abraham’s bosom, Gabriel bringing the good news to the Madonna, and figures of our Lord, a bishop, and a priest. The clock above all these has a 24-hour dial; centuries before the BBC tried to make us count in twenty-fours this was a 24-hour clock, and is the only clock in Cornwall mentioned in an inventory of Tudor days.
The porch, with an upper room, a pelican over the doorway, and a stoup with a grotesque head, brings us into a spacious interior with three fine old black and white roofs with painted bosses, Norman stones in the chancel arcade, and glowing windows with 12 saints, 4 figures representing the virtues, and scenes of the Annunciation and the Nativity. One of the windows is interesting for having flowers and faces hidden in the cusps of its tracery.
The alabaster pulpit, new last century, has 34 figures carved on it, among them the Good Shepherd, Paul preaching, and the Sermon on the Mount. There is a little pulpit carved in one of the 20 old bench-ends fixed on the walls of the tower; it shows a fox preaching with one paw over the pulpit, the fox having his eye on a lady kneeling near by. We noticed on this old panelling a miner’s spade and ladle, and a dragon’s head.
Perhaps the rarest single possession of the church is its massive Norman font, the bowl carved with extraordinary creatures and resting on columns ending in human faces. Its magnificent cover is like a little dome-crowned temple with Mary and Joseph inside with St Anne and Simeon receiving the Child in the Temple. Round about are four guardian angels, one with a boy, one with a maid, one with a fish, and one with a pitcher, and the balancing weight is a golden dove. The setting of the font is very striking, the baptistry having panelled walls and an alabaster mosaic showing the Baptism in Jordan and mothers bringing their children to the Master. Above is a glowing Jesse window. A fine piece of work, the baptistry was given in memory of Elizabeth Shilson, who died in 1922, her husband hurrying on the work so that he might see it finished before he died. He lived just long enough to have his wish.
Four names we noticed here: Stephen Hugo, an 18th-century vicar for 62 years and Richard Hennah, vicar for 50 years till Waterloo; Samuel Drew who worked as a boy here for twopence a day, became a shoemaker, smuggler, and a Methodist preacher, and is remembered as a philosopher; and John William Colenso, the Bishop of the Zulus. who was bom here in the year before Waterloo.
Friend of the Zulus
HE was a Victorian, dying in 1883, but the story of his life might belong to the age of the great persecutions.
The way in which, as a poor youth, he secured an education, attaining the highest rank as a mathematician and nobly repaying to the last farthing those who had supported him at Cambridge, is a shining example of self-help. A disastrous fire at Harrow beggared him, but his losses were recouped by his books on mathematics, and it was as a man of some substance that he went to Africa as Bishop of Natal.
He threw himself with enthusiastic energy not only into the conversion of the Zulus but into their education. He took boys from the jungle and made scholars and craftsmen of them, so that, when he translated English into Zulu and Zulu into English, these reclaimed sons of the wilds were his printers and literary assistants. It was while he was translating the Bible for his sable flock that certain disquieting doubts penetrated the bishop’s mind.
As his converts read his story of Genesis they would ask him: “Is this all really true?” and he wrote: “My heart answered in the words of the Prophet, Shall a man speak lies in the name of the Lord? I dared not do so.” He was fifty years ahead of his time, and the bishops and clergy of Africa, supported by religious societies at home, fell fiercely upon him.
The conflict was long and embittered. As volume after volume of his writings appeared, the storm increased in vehemence, until an ecclesiastical court calmly pronounced excommunication against him. On Colenso’s appeal to the Privy Council the arrogant pronouncement was at once swept aside, and the bishop continued his ministrations, to the unabated satisfaction of his diocese. But the campaign raged in other parts of Africa and in certain circles at home, with the result that religious societies diverted their contributions to another see, and finally the trustees of the Colonial Bishoprics Fund refused to pay his episcopal income.
Again the Civil Law of the Empire was invoked, and again the bishop was vindicated and the conduct of his enemies sternly reprehended. Not less furious was the resentment against him aroused by his support of the cause of the natives oppressed by white men. Once more he triumphed, and was growing daily in success and authority when death laid him low, but left his name secure in fame.
Flickr.
Probus, Cornwall
This is, of course, bollocks for the casual visitor - the vestry is locked and the chances of gaining entry must be extremely remote [this is also bollocks since it's not in the vestry after all]. Discarding his excitement over the hunky punks, which are, after all, run of the mill grotesques, and that it sports the tallest tower in Cornwall [willy waving] I would give this a miss - except for the vainglorious tomb of Christopher Hawkins [he died in 1829 but is supported by four civil war cavaliers] - it's ludicrously glorious.
I forgot the, to me, quite rare James the Second Royal arms which emphasise the Royalist sympathies both in the Civil War and the Glorious Revolution - we'll see more evidence of this soon.
A quick Google seems to show that even the Catholic church is not sure who St Probus was and I wouldn't take Mee's word for it.
20 prophets and saints, among them St Probus and St Grace, who are believed to lie under the altar here. Two skulls found last century are supposed to be theirs.
Tuesday, 22 October 2019
Truro Cathedral, Cornwall
I knew from our initial conversation that Truro is a Victorian build and I was, therefore [perhaps predictably], expecting to find it disappointing - despite his assurances that it was of merit. To my surprise he was absolutely correct and I found it to be of considerable merit. It doesn't contain as much interest as an older cathedral and the glass is poor quality but it is well designed and executed - even if it is stylistically all over the place which I think adds to its charm. Oh and the Tinworth panel is extraordinary.
Of the parish church of Truro, ST MARY, Pearson allowed the S aisle to remain, while the rest (with a spire of 128 ft, rebuilt in 1768) was pulled down. The aisle, of 1504-18, is indeed one of the most ornate Gothic structures in Cornwall, probably by the same masons as Probus tower. It has the same decoration of the plinth in two tiers, the same use of niches for statuary, the same decorating of the buttresses. The window spandrels have tracery, and the battlements also are adorned with quatrefoils. The S windows are large, of four lights, the E window of five. The interior had its arcade with piers of standard Cornish design with plain capitals and arches nearly semi circular. Some of the roof timbers are still to be seen, and a few bits of old glass.
The new FURNISHINGS of the cathedral are on the whole not fortunate. Artists of conventional tastes have been used, not those of stronger individuality. STAINED GLASS by Clayton & Bell, except on the S side of the old aisle, where there is good glass by Warrington (1840s;TK). - CHOIR STALLS and BISHOP’S THRONE designed by Pearson himself. - PULPIT. Of a comfortably bulgy shape and with inlay of local workmanship. - PLATE. Gilt Chalice and Paten by F W (see Holy Trinity, Hull, and Batford St Martins, Wilts.), 1619-20; two similar Flagons, 1623-4; several C18 pieces; gold Chalice and Paten designed by Pearson; all the rest also C19. - MONUMENTS. In the crypt two lifesize kneeling alabaster figures of c.1620, not well carved. - Richard Robarts d. 1614 (‘of his age seventy or thereabouts’) and wife, a large affair with the two effigies reclining stiffly and behind each other, double columns l. and r., and on their entablatures two very good smaller figures of Father Time and Death. The carving of the larger figures is by no means good. - Some late C18 and early C19 monuments to Vyvyans, too high up to be seen.
I don't have any of the relevant
Truro Cathedral is probably the last considerable work of imitative Gothic to be built in England, having been consecrated in 1887 and only finally completed in 1903. Its architect, the late J. L. Pearson, R.A., designed it in distinctive version of the style of the thirteenth century, tinged with a French influence that is apparent in the general loftiness of its proportions inside and out, and in the attenuation of its towers and spires; and there is not a feature that has not its precedent somewhere in this country or in Northern France. To the modern eye, this unyielding literalism is the chief defect of the design, and the plan has all the intricacies of its thirteenth-century prototypes, and accordingly bears little relation to the requirements of English Protestantism. Ranking in its dimensions with Wells or Norwich, the spacious interior is treated with an admirable restraint and mastery of proportion, and the incorporation of part of the fabric of an old Perpendicular parish church to the south-east, adding a third aisle to the quire, results in some fine vistas. Generally speaking, there can be little doubt that Pearson's work is among the most impressive achievements of the later Gothic Revival, but despite its technical cleverness, its conception is inevitably anachronistic, and it never rises to the dignity of living architecture.*
Live ye for England, we for England died.
Flickr.